We take great pride in serving our customers, and it shows.
Welcome to Ebeneezer's Cafe & Creamery
Full Service Restaurant in Sherrill, New York



Originally planned as an ice cream parlor/coffee bar some twenty years ago, Ebeneezer's Cafe & Creamery quickly became a full-service restaurant. Ebeneezer's is conveniently located on Sherrill Rd in the center of beautiful Sherrill, New York. 

As soon as you sit down you will be tempted with various types of espressos including cappuccino, daily flavored coffees, teas and juices. Their cappuccino is brewed on site, the real deal.  

Ebeneezer's lunch menu consists of an array of sandwiches including Ham, Tuna and Egg salad, deli meats, as well as a hand pattied "man-sized" Burger served on a kaiser roll. Daily specials created by chef Joel Agan truly define the word special. Like the Pot Roast sandwich served on grilled focaccia bread made famous at the Sherrill park fest.  

The lighter side of the menu has garden, julienne, Caesar and Chicken Caesar salads and homemade soup.

For dessert, try a slice of Jack Griffith's apple pie. This is the recipe Evan's grandfather brought from Wales many years ago. Other treats include creamy Rice Pudding, freshly baked Pies an awsome Chocolate Cake and of course the famous ( to live for) Bread Pudding with Custard Sauce. All home made of course.

After lunch, those who want to spend an afternoon as their British counterparts do, should consider Ebeneezer's Afternoon Tea from 2-3pm, Monday through Saturday. Customers enjoy homemade scones, a biscuit-like pastry served with fresh strawberrry jam and whipped cream with a pot of tea.

Fridays will feature dinner specials ranging from their famous Fresh Haddock Fish Fry to Baked Mahi Mahi; all prepared fresh to order.

And don't forget the ice cream! The Ice Cream Parlor is open everyday of ice cream season from 11am till 9 pm. Although the menu is embellished with a poem about 28 flavors of ice cream with such oddities as tapioca smoke baloney and onion dumpling double dip, Ebeneezer's has an actual list of 21 more palatable flavors, including hard and soft ice cream.

And don't overlook the specialty sundaes, each named for a member of the family except The Turtle, a tribute to hot fudge, caramel topping and whipped cream. 

Even as the menu and ambiance grow at Ebeneezer's, quality service will always be a hallmark.      






© 2011 Ebeneezer's Cafe & Creamery
All Rights Reserved
624 Sherrill Road, Sherrill, NY 13461